Our Trusted Carriers

Brenda Bedford is the owner of Bethlehem Star Insurance Agency, which she proudly owns alongside her husband, Al Nicholas. Together, they have spent more than 16 years building an agency rooted in integrity, family values, and exceptional customer service. Originally established as the Bedford Nicholas Nationwide Agency, they later transitioned to an independent agency to provide clients with greater flexibility, more insurance options, and personalized solutions tailored to each individual’s needs.

With more than 22 years of experience in the insurance industry, Brenda began her career with Nationwide, where she developed a strong foundation in protecting individuals, families, and businesses. Her passion for helping others, combined with her commitment to honesty and personalized service, has shaped the culture of Bethlehem Star Insurance Agency from the very beginning.

Brenda and Al believe that an insurance agency should feel like family. They have created an environment where employees are valued, clients are treated like neighbors, and lasting relationships are built on trust. Together, they are committed to the continued growth of the agency through ongoing education, professional development, and embracing innovative technology and strategies that allow their team to better serve the community. Their vision has always been simple: provide knowledgeable guidance, genuine care, and insurance solutions that give clients confidence and peace of mind.